With personal casco cover, the deductible is mostly a given – in a fleet, it is a tool. How much of a claim you carry yourself directly affects the premium, how small claims are handled, and the claims record. This article gives you a framework for building a deductible policy.
- The deductible is the part of a claim you keep – in exchange, the premium is typically lower.
- In a fleet, the deductible can be tuned by category: different on a new, valuable car than on an ageing one.
- A well-calibrated deductible filters the mass of small claims out of the statistics – one tool for protecting your loss ratio.
- A deductible policy is a matter of calculation: claim frequency, average claim size, reserves.
What is a deductible, really?
It is risk-sharing – but the form the deductible takes varies from quote to quote. With a fixed-amount deductible, you genuinely take on only the lower band of any claim; with a percentage deductible (combined with a minimum amount), which is more common in Hungarian practice, a share of the claim value falls to you even on a large claim – so when comparing quotes, you need to look at the deductible type and the minimum together. The larger the band you carry, the lower the premium typically is – and vice versa. There is no single "right" deductible: the right one is whatever fits your claims pattern and reserves. That is why a deductible policy is not something buried in the small print of a quote, but a decision to make upfront, before requesting quotes.
The fleet angle: small claims and loss ratio
Fleets have a characteristic claims pattern: lots of small claims (parking scrapes, mirrors, windscreens) and rarer large ones. Reporting small claims weighs on the loss ratio – so it can happen that a low deductible costs more over time than it pays back in claims. That is why, for many fleets, a higher deductible combined with an internal small-claims fund works well: the insurance covers the real large risk, and the statistics stay cleaner. Details on this dilemma: reporting small claims.
Tuned by category
The deductible does not have to be the same across the whole fleet: a lower one can make sense on a new, high-value vehicle, a higher one on an ageing unit – in line with the casco matrix described in the fleet casco article. One thing to watch for financed vehicles: the financier may set a maximum deductible – in that case, the finance agreement governs.
How is the decision made?
From data: how many claims there were in recent years, at what average value, and how large an unexpected expense you can absorb without straining your cash flow. It is worth doing this calculation before requesting quotes – in the renewal cycle, this is part of my preparation work. If the claims trend worsens, raising the deductible is one point of intervention: a separate article covers this – raising the deductible as a tool.
Introducing a deductible policy, step by step
The proven order: first, mapping out the claims pattern – claim frequency and average claim size by category, from the last few years' claims list. Second, clarifying the reserve question with financial management: how large a deductible you can absorb without straining your cash flow, and whether there should be an internal small-claims fund. Third, documenting the decision: how large a deductible per category, who decides on settling from the fund, and how this is communicated to drivers. Finally, requesting quotes – now with a finished set of deductible principles, so the quotes can be compared on equal terms. At renewal, the cycle closes: the claims record shows whether the levels were well calibrated, and whether they need adjusting.
A question tailored to your own fleet? Book a free 20-minute consultation →
